365 Days of Women Writers

Women writers only – no boys allowed

Archive for the ‘mary robinette kowal’ Category

Day 7: American Changeling by Mary Robinette Kowal

leave a comment »

When I was at Clarion, one of the things the instructors told us was that it wasn’t enough to write a competently crafted story – they were all over the place. There needed to be something more, something that would raise it above the level of the ordinary and forgettable.

American Changeling doesn’t have the something more. It’s competently crafted, moves along from point to point and wraps up sufficiently well, but there’s nothing there to catch my interest. It’s a textbook” get the magic widget and accomplish the magic task despite unexpected setbacks” type of story.

When I read the author notes, Kowal indicated that she wanted to write a story where the chosen one didn’t have the task thrust upon her, but instead had been preparing for it her whole life. Unfortunately, this isn’t enough to breathe life into it.

Written by Chance

September 24, 2010 at 5:22 pm